Training film · 6 minutes
Nip It in the Bloom! Why chocolate turns white
White streaks, or a dusty white crust? That’s bloom, and there are two kinds: fat bloom and sugar bloom. They look alike, but the causes and the cures are different. This animated training film follows Chip and the Inspector from the kitchen to the factory floor.
The film plays from YouTube once you press play. Sound on.
What it covers
- How to tell fat bloom from sugar bloom, by look and touch
- What fat bloom is: coarse fat crystals at the surface, and the crystal forms behind it (Beta, Form V and Form VI)
- What causes it: tempering and cooling, warm storage, time, oil from nuts, and fillings
- Sugar bloom: the fridge, humid air and the dew point
- How factories keep bloom out, from the cooling tunnel to the packing room
- The best clue to the cause: when the bloom appeared
- Whether bloomed chocolate is safe to eat, and what can be saved
Fat bloom or sugar bloom?
- Fat bloom leaves grey-white streaks and swirls. It feels smooth, even greasy, and a warm fingertip may smear it.
- Sugar bloom leaves a white, gritty crust that stays put.
What causes fat bloom
Tempered chocolate sets as tiny, stable Beta crystals, packed so neatly they give a mirror shine. Fat bloom is coarse fat crystals at the surface. They scatter the light, so we see grey.
- Poor tempering, or cooling too cold, too fast. Our film Keep Your Temper! covers tempering.
- Warmth. Each warm spell melts the softest fats, which set again, bigger.
- Time. Tempering makes Form V. Given months, it can turn into Form VI, the most stable form of all, but its crystals grow coarse, and that’s bloom. Warmth hurries it along.
- Oil from nuts. All nuts are full of oil: a hazelnut is about 60% oil, locked away in tiny cells. Cut a nut cleanly and only the sliced cells open; bash it, crush it or tumble it about, and far more cells burst. The free oil seeps into the chocolate, softens it and hurries its crystals on to Form VI. With crushed nuts somewhere warm, fat bloom can break out in days, even in well-tempered chocolate.
- Fillings with soft or incompatible fats, from praline to some vegetable fats. Choose fats that suit cocoa butter, and an even shell.
What causes sugar bloom
Cold chocolate meets warm, humid air, and dew forms, like on a cold glass. The dew dissolves sugar at the surface. As it dries, the sugar crystallises again: a white, gritty crust.
So skip the fridge if you can. If chocolate must go in, seal it airtight, and let it warm up before you open it.
In the factory
Cool too cold, too fast, and the crystals set unstable, so cool it in stages. In a packing room at 22°C and 65% humidity, the dew point is about 15°C, so chocolate coming out at 12°C sweats. The last cooling zone warms it to just above the dew point.
Some factories give fresh enrobed chocolates a controlled warm rest, a heat treatment, to prevent or delay bloom. It can’t cure it.
Temperatures shown are typical figures, not settings for every product or line, so always follow your chocolate supplier’s specification.
When did it appear?
The best clue to the cause is when the bloom appeared.
- Straight after cooling: the temper, or the tunnel.
- Within days: unstable crystals, or free oil from nuts.
- After weeks or months: warm storage, oily fillings, Form VI.
- After the fridge, or a humid spell: sugar bloom.
To check nuts, there’s another paper test: the bigger the oil stain, the more free oil.
Already bloomed?
If it’s bloom, not mould, it’s still safe to eat. Plain fat-bloomed chocolate can be melted and re-tempered, but sugar bloom won’t melt away.
The Bloom Buster’s Code
- Temper it right.
- Cool it gently.
- Store it cool, steady and dark.
- Keep it dry.
- Cut nuts clean.
- And mind the dew point.